Remodel or Move: Which is Best for You?

By in News

• Here’s When to Renovate Your Home and When to Move Instead •

Once you have lived in your home for a while, it is not uncommon to realize that it no longer meets your current lifestyle needs.

Whether it be a family expansion, changes in mobility, or a shift to working remotely, the space that has worked in the past may no longer be suitable to your circumstances today.

So then the question becomes: should I renovate or find a new home and move? Unfortunately, there isn’t one answer that’s right for everyone. However, there are some factors you can consider to help you make the right choice. Here’s what you need to know.

Remodel or Move: Which is Best for You?

Remodeling: Pros

  • You love the area where you live. Your neighbors are great, schools are top-notch, and your favorite coffee shop is just down the street. If you like your neighborhood, staying in your current home is one of the biggest pros.
  • If you enjoy DIY work around the house and have some spare time, you may be able to complete parts of the remodel yourself. Not only can this be personally rewarding, but it can also help add value to your home.
  • Your home already feels like, well, home. Remodeling allows you to take this feeling even further, making your space uniquely yours. If you don’t like something the previous owners had installed, take it out and start over.
  • Remodeling can provide significant financial advantages over moving. Even though it could get expensive, especially with extensive work, it can still cost you less and create added sweat equity.

Remodeling: Cons

  • Remodeling can be a lengthy project. When undergoing a home improvement project, you’ll likely need to adjust your lifestyle temporarily. For example, if you are an avid cook who is remodeling the kitchen, you may need to start ordering out while your favorite space is out of commission for weeks or months at a time.
  • Remodeling can be messy. Things get displaced during a remodel. Don’t be surprised if your spacious and calming living room becomes cluttered storage for some time. Additionally, you’ll likely see some dust cover your space during the remodel. If you don’t handle messes well or have allergies, you may struggle during a remodel.
  • Remodeling costs can add up quickly. There are often additional expenses that pop up during a remodel. For instance, your goal may be to redo only a couple of walls — but then you find faulty or outdated wiring in the process. Or, perhaps the cost of raw materials goes up mid-project. These types of unforeseen circumstances can drive up your project cost significantly.
  • Remodeling can get off schedule. Similar to a budget, sometimes it’s nearly impossible to control unforeseen setbacks. If you choose to remodel, it’s essential to keep your project’s timing in mind and ensure enough cushion to accomplish everything you plan.

Moving: Pros

  • One of the biggest pros of leaving your old home behind is that you’ll finally gain the space to meet your lifestyle needs. For instance, if you’re seeking an open concept floor plan, but your current home’s layout is the exact opposite, it may be easier for you to buy a new home instead of undertaking a costly home improvement project.
  • In some instances, it could make more financial sense to move. Consider cost versus value when thinking of remodeling your home. You may spend $100,000 in renovations to only increase your property value by $20,000 or so. On the other hand, you may come out ahead financially by purchasing a new home.

Moving: Cons

  • People often hold a strong emotional attachment to their home, especially if they have lived there for a while. If you raised children in the house, you might be reminded of joyous holiday mornings every time you walk past the living room.
  • You could end up paying more to buy a new home than you would to remodel. When considering a move, remember to factor in several costs and fees associated with buying and selling a home, including real estate agent commission, closing costs, and more.

The Bottom Line

The first step in deciding whether to remodel or buy a new home is to think about the scope of changes you’re looking to complete and obtain an estimate. If you choose to purchase a new home after weighing the pros and cons, working with the right real estate agent can make all the difference.

Our trusted local agent experts are always here to get you more out of your most significant investment. Have questions? Call us at (858) 880-0195 or email to get started with Reali today.

Share This
About The Author
Portia Green, REALTOR®

Portia Green is a highly experienced full-time REALTOR® specializing in the representation of Sellers, heralded by her clients as data-driven and an effective negotiator. Producing $25M total in residential sales volume, Portia's goal is to help her clients achieve the best results when selling their homes and to make their experience an enjoyable one. She has successfully sold real estate since 2008 and has gained an in-depth knowledge of local real estate markets & seasonal trends. Portia has achieved a 100% customer satisfaction rating and wants to share her expertise & personal service with you in the sale of your home. When listing your home with Portia Green and Compass, you'll receive the hands-on service you need and desire. Portia will help you manage the entire process of selling your home from pricing, preparing and staging the house, to marketing, negotiating offers, inspections, all the way to closing. She will recommend skilled vendors for any job needed, personally host Open Houses, and ensure that all showings are accompanied. At Compass, Portia offers a wise no-nonsense way to sell your home for the best price and the least hassle. With a keen eye for staging & preparing listings to maximize Buyer appeal, all of Portia Green's listings are professionally photographed using HDR (High Dynamic Range) photography to provide the highest quality photos in the industry. Professionally printed marketing materials are prepared for all Open Houses. We also capture a 3D scan of your home that creates an interactive walkthrough online along with a custom-designed floor plan and targeted digital marketing campaigns on Google & the most popular social media channels. Compass participates in the Multiple Listing Service, which is the local real estate database of homes listed for sale that all REALTORS® use in helping their Buyers find houses. Your home will appear on every real estate website, in its best light, making a stunning camera-ready debut. Portia Green's home valuation expertise and extensive experience in comparative market analysis will help price your home accurately. She has refined her skills to help you pinpoint which features of your home will result in more showings and better results. Her mantra is for you to be ready to sell your home and feel good about that first. Portia knows that home inspectors always find a problem; that drones take some of the best photos in town; and that her eyebrows will grow to the floor in the time it takes her to read everything that's happening with your HOA, but that doesn't mean she won't do it anyway. Eyebrows be damned. You'll always need a place to unplug, connect, dream, grow, or just be yourself. That makes what Portia does even more meaningful. She’s ready to go the extra mile to help you find just the place. Whether you're selling your very first home, offloading an investment property, or want a vacation getaway with passive income, she is attentive to the details of every home sale. Portia helps busy people navigate this crazy real estate market like a pro, so don't be shy. Every great relationship starts with free advice and a friendly chat. Ask as many questions as you need to. Selling houses is her jam!